Last updated: May 15, 2026
On March 31, 2023, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) listed Northern long-eared bats (NLEB) as “endangered” under the federal Endangered Species Act. In New York, all federally endangered species that occur in the state are afforded endangered status under the New York State Endangered and Threatened Species Law (Environmental Conservation Law Section 11-0535) and its implementing regulations under 6 NYCRR Part 182 (Part 182). As recently as 2005, the NLEB was New York State's third most common bat species with populations estimated at or above 500,000 animals and were found through all forested habitat in the state. The federal listing was the result of a dramatic population decline throughout most of the species' range. This decline has been caused by white-nose syndrome (WNS), a disease caused by an invasive fungus that ultimately causes affected hibernating bats to starve to death over the winter. Since WNS was first discovered in New York in 2006, a 98% decline in the abundance of NLEB has been observed. DEC is actively working with researchers from around North America to develop a management approach that will aid the recovery of this species. In the meantime, legal protections afforded by the listing status of the bat are focused on minimizing and avoiding direct loss of the remaining individuals by protecting the known hibernation sites and limiting forest habitat impacts from activities that occur where and when NLEB are most likely to be present. Since 2007, NLEB still occurs rarely throughout most of New York, with the highest density of remaining bats in Suffolk County, where the milder winters reduce the impacts of WNS on the species.
After listing NLEB as endangered, USFWS updated their NLEB guidance on October 23, 2024. The new guidance established a 3-mile buffer for all acoustic detections of NLEB on Long Island, expanding the area USFWS considers suitable habitat. The 2024 federal guidance also notes a higher density of NLEB in suitable habitat on Long Island than is found elsewhere in the species range. Accordingly, the current federal guidance evaluates the impact of cutting individual trees. No matter where they occur in Nassau and Suffolk counties, projects that are subject to review by USFWS may be required to adopt practices to avoid adverse impacts to NLEB.
In comparison to the federal method, DEC takes a more prescriptive approach focused on the protection of the bats themselves through accurate identification of NLEB occupied habitat (see definitions below). Consistent with Part 182 regulations, DEC defines occupied habitat by using a 1.5-mile buffer that is based on the home range size of NLEB on Long Island and utilizes acoustic detections only where data demonstrate repeated use and essential behavior of the animals.
Because USFWS does not use the same definition of occupied habitat as DEC (Figure 1), in situations where there is a federal nexus USFWS may apply different restrictions than DEC. The federal review process is initiated through the USFWS IPAC website. DEC maintains limited jurisdiction over projects where there is a federal nexus. Under the federal Endangered Species Act DEC cannot be less restrictive than federal requirements.
If your project has a federal nexus as defined below, you will need to use the USFWS IPaC Decision Key and abide by any conditions placed upon your project by the federal agency providing funding or permissions.
To provide clarity to project applicants on the varying State and Federal approaches to protection of NLEB, this guidance addresses requirements under New York State’s Part 182 regulations for land use change projects associated with the protection of NLEB in Nassau and Suffolk counties. This guidance does not create or modify any statutory or regulatory rights or obligations.
Any project that is determined to be likely to adversely affect NLEB will need to avoid those adverse effects or pursue an Incidental Take Permit under Part 182. Incidental Take permits require mitigation of any impacts that cannot be avoided or sufficiently minimized. Incidental Take Permits must include mitigation that results in a net conservation benefit to the impacted species. Net conservation benefit is met when, compared to status of the species before the project is implemented, the species and/or its habitat are enhanced after the implementation of the project’s mitigation
measures. For additional information on this Long Island specific guidance, please contact the DEC Region 1 Wildlife Office at (631) 444-0310.
Please note that additional state or federal endangered species may also be present and DEC may have additional jurisdiction under other regulations regarding air, water and other natural resources. View more information on how DEC addresses listed species.
Definitions
For the purposes of the NLEB guidance provided here for Nassau and Suffolk counties, the following terms are defined for ease of reference:
- Federal nexus – projects receiving funding from a federal source, conducted in cooperation with a federal agency, requiring a federal permit, or taking place on federally-owned property.
- Land use change – the conversion of any portion of forest containing suitable habitat, or the area of suitable habitat surrounding a roost or hibernation site, to another form that will affect NLEB use of the area.
Bats utilize 1.5-mile home ranges, with USFWS requiring 5-mile activity buffers around hibernacula.
- Tree clearing – includes cutting or other means of knocking down, bringing down, topping, trimming or pruning of suitable roost trees.
- Occupied habitat – as defined in 6 NYCRR Subpart 182.2(p), the places within New York where DEC has documented species listed as endangered or threatened engaged in behaviors essential to their survival and reproduction. These areas are generally composed of the suitable habitat within an area equal to an average home range around where the species was documented.
- Suitable habitat – includes a variety of forested areas, particularly those near hibernation sites and roost sites, along with wooded areas near water features that are used for foraging in the active season. Suitable habitat may also include some adjacent and interspersed non-forested habitats such as emergent wetlands, forest clearings and adjacent edges of agricultural fields, old fields and pastures. Foraging typically occurs along and within forested corridors, such as streams, trails, or forest clearings/edges. Snags, cavity trees, and trees with cracks and crevices are preferred for summer roosts and maternity colonies. As a generalist species NLEB use trees of various species and sizes as roosts, with most trees and branches used by the species measuring ≥3” diameter.
- Active season occurrence zone (see Figure 1) – includes the 1.5-mile area surrounding NLEB records including mist net captures, hibernacula, and roost locations.
- Acoustic only records zone (see Figure 2) – includes the 1.5-mile area surrounding any NLEB acoustic record where data demonstrates repeated use by the species.
The records referenced above are updated annually as new occurrences are confirmed and will be uploaded to the Environmental Resource Mapper and the Environmental Assessment Form for review in relation to your project. Please email the Region 1 Wildlife Office.
Guidance for Land Use Change Projects that Include Tree Clearing
Because all sites have not been surveyed and suitable habitat is present throughout Nassau and Suffolk counties, DEC recommends clearing of suitable habitat during the winter inactive season, December 1 through February 28, when bats are hibernating and not present on the landscape to avoid or minimize impacts to this endangered species. Depending on project location, type, and size, projects may fall under the jurisdiction of the NYS Endangered and Threatened Species Law and implementing regulations. Projects under such jurisdiction may be required to implement all tree clearing during the winter inactive season and take additional actions to avoid and minimize impacts to NLEB, with mitigation required if avoidance cannot be achieved.
If DEC determines the proposed activity is not subject to an endangered and threatened species jurisdictional determination, DEC’s determination is valid for one year from date of issuance as long as there are no changes to the activities or locations proposed in the jurisdictional request and no federally listed species are confirmed within the project footprint prior to the expiration of one year.
Project specific determinations will be made by DEC with a focus on avoiding and
minimizing potential impacts to the endangered NLEB:
Land Use Change Projects of 10 Acres or More
- All projects affecting 10 acres or more of suitable habitat that are located within the active season occurrence zone (see Figure 1) or within the acoustic only records zone (Figure 2) and regardless of when tree removal is planned will need to be reviewed by DEC Region 1 Division of Environmental Permits and a Division of Fish and Wildlife Biologist for impacts to listed bat species.
- This review will evaluate the location of any tree clearing in relation to known occurrences. To initiate this review, you must apply for an Endangered and Threatened Species (ETS) Jurisdictional Determination. To obtain application forms and instructions on submission, please email your inquiry.
- For land use change projects affecting 10 acres or more of suitable habitat occurring outside of the active season occurrence zone (Figure 1) or outside of the acoustic only records zone (Figure 2), DEC recommends site specific surveys for bats be conducted in accordance with the USFWS approved protocol.
- Please note that USFWS considers all forested habitat in Nassau and Suffolk counties to be suitable habitat:
- Any proposal affecting 10 acres or more of suitable habitat with a federal nexus (e.g. federal funding, permits), including those outside of known occurrence areas, will likely be required to adhere to time-of-year restrictions and other best management practices unless appropriate site-specific surveys indicate the absence of the species.
- All proposals for surveys must be reviewed by a DEC Division of Fish and Wildlife Biologist for approval prior to initiation of any work. All resulting final reports must also be submitted for review. If no listed bats are detected, there is no need for additional DEC review for listed bat species. If listed bats are detected, you must apply for an ETS Jurisdictional Determination as described above.
Land Use Change Projects of Less Than 10 Acres
- All projects affecting less than 10 acres of suitable habitat that fall outside of the identified active season occurrence zones (Figure 1) or outside of the acoustic only records zone (Figure 2) can proceed with tree clearing at any time of year without additional review by DEC. If a project occurs in suitable habitat, DEC recommends completing the clearing during the winter inactive season, Dec 1 – Feb 28, when bats are hibernating and not present on the landscape.
- All projects affecting less than 10 acres that fall within the acoustic only records zone (Figure 2) but outside of the active season occurrence zone (Figure 1), can proceed with tree clearing during the winter inactive season, Dec 1 – Feb 28, when bats are hibernating and not present on the landscape. If all clearing is completed during this time of year, no additional review or permit by DEC is necessary. See the Environmental Resource Mapper to view these occurrence record zones including occupied habitat buffers.
- Any projects that fall within the active season occurrence zones (Figure 1) will need to be reviewed by a DEC Region 1 Division of Fish and Wildlife Biologist for project specific guidance and adhere to additional protections, including a prohibition on clearing of trees 3-inches Diameter at Breast Height (DBH) or greater within 150 feet of DEC-identified maternity roosts. Projects that are unable to adhere to these additional protections will require an Incidental Take permit under the Part 182 regulations that implement the New York State Endangered Species Act. This review will focus on the location of any necessary tree clearing in relation to known occurrences. To request this review, you must apply for an Endangered and Threatened Species (ETS) Jurisdictional Determination. To obtain application forms and instructions on submission, please email your inquiry.
- Any projects that occur within identified active season occurrences (Figure 1) that cannot complete all tree cutting and clearing during the winter inactive season will need to be reviewed by a DEC Region 1 Division of Fish and Wildlife Biologist for project specific guidance. Cutting during the active season will require an Endangered and Threatened Species Incidental Take permit if avoidance is not possible and include appropriate mitigation measures. Typical conditions for active season cutting include, but may not be limited to:
- Avoiding tree cutting until after the critical periods of spring emergence and pup rearing (mid-August).
- Leaving uncut all known roost trees, and any trees equal to or greater than 3-inches DBH within DEC-determined buffers of a summer occurrence or hibernaculum.
- Leaving uncut all snags and cavity trees (PDF) unless their removal is necessary for protection of human life or property.
- Restrictions on drilling, blasting, outdoor lighting, pesticide application or other activities may be required to limit impacts to NLEB.
- Mitigation measures that result in a net conservation benefit to NLEB (e.g., improved foraging habitat, finding new hibernacula or roosts, hibernaculum creation or protection, protecting habitat around known roosts or hibernacula).