| Water | Townships | Species | Regulations | Comments | Contour Map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Casterline Pond | Homer | Panfish, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout | Statewide Regulations Apply | 9 acres, public access site. | Yes |
| Goodale Lake | Preble | Panfish, Pickerel | 45 acres, shallow, weedy lake. | No | |
| Little York Lake | Preble, Homer | Panfish, Pickerel, Rainbow Trout, Brown Trout | 150 acres, deep lake providing a diverse fishery. | Yes | |
| Tri-County Pond | Harford, Caroline | Panfish, Rainbow Trout | 1.7 acres, semi-remote pond located at the intersection of Cortland, Tioga and Tompkins County lines. | No | |
| Skaneateles Lake | Scott | Panfish, Pickerel, Lake Trout | Finger Lakes and Tributaries Regulations Apply | 8,960 acres, ice fishing at the north and south ends | Yes |
| Papish Pond | Cincinnatus | Panfish, Pickerel | Statewide Regulations Apply | 19 acres, shallow, weedy lake. | No |
| Tully Lake | Preble | Panfish, Pickerel | 230 acres, shallow, weedy lake. | Yes |
For information on ice fishing basics and safety, visit our Learn to Ice Fish webpage.
Lake Contour Maps for Cortland County